Part two of our massive Blue Buffalo cat food reviews roundup, this time with a focus on Blue Buffalo wet cat food reviews.
Advertising and affordability are two factors that have led Blue Buffalo to flourish as a cat food brand. But it’s the wholesome and nutritious ingredients that make Blue Buffalo a top cat food choice with our #1 favorite Blue Buffalo Wilderness Wild Delights.
Blue Buffalo provides quality and balanced nutrition that brings cat parents peace of mind while going easy on their wallets!
Our top 3 picks for Blue Buffalo wet cat food
- Blue Buffalo Wilderness Wild Delights
- Blue Buffalo Freedom Grain Free
- Blue Buffalo Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipes
Plus even more great Blue Buffalo choices!
- Blue Buffalo Wilderness
- Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Flaked Wet Cat Food
- Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Pate Wet Cat Food
- Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Meaty Morsels Wet Cat Food
- Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Kitten Pate Wet Cat Food
- Baby Blue Healthy Growth Formula Kitten Wet Cat Food
We’re going to give you all the details on the wet cat foods Blue Buffalo has on the market. This round of up Blue Buffalo wet cat food reviews includes canned foods from the following lines: Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet, Blue Buffalo Wilderness, Blue Buffalo Limited Ingredient, and Blue Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free.
Let’s get to it!
Blue Buffalo Wilderness varieties
Blue Buffalo’s Wilderness wet cat food for adults comes in three varieties: the traditional grain-free Wilderness line, which comes in pate form, and the Wilderness Wild Delights line that features meaty morsels and minced meat, and the Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipes. The Wilderness line also has a small line of canned wet food for kittens.
1. Blue Buffalo Wilderness Wild Delights – our top pick!
In the same spirit as the original Blue Buffalo Wilderness line, Blue’s Wilderness Wild Delights are built on a foundation of premium unprocessed and top quality meats like salmon, duck, and chicken. There are no preservatives, fillers, artificial additives, corn, soy, wheat, grains, or gluten.
Unlike the pate form of the traditional Wilderness wet food, Wilderness Wild Delights feature chunky meat morsels coated with gravy. As with the original Wilderness recipe, this wet food is enriched with essential vitamins, minerals, amino acids, and omega-3s. The high-protein, low-carb formula, makes this a solid choice for cat parents concerned about their kitties weight or muscle maintenance.
Pros
- The meaty morsels are appealing for cats who hate pate
- The meat chunks are soft enough for senior kitties and cats with missing teeth
- High protein and highly digestible
- Many cats love the thick gravy
- Limited vegetable ingredients
Cons
- Premium prices
- For adult and mature cats only
- Not appropriate for cats with fish allergies or sensitivities
- Cats who only like pate might not like the texture
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
2. Blue Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free Varieties
Blue Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free is a gluten-free wet cat food ideal for indoor adult kitties with sensitive tummies, skin conditions, and even some chronic illnesses like diabetes. The unique blend of high-quality meat proteins, veggie proteins, fruits, vitamins, minerals, omega-3s, and other essential fatty acids and nutrients provides balanced nutrition.
Blue Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free is a high-protein, low-calorie choice with moderate fats to support indoor cats slightly less active lifestyles. Blue Buffalo Freedom Grain-Free is a solid choice for maintaining a healthy weight, supporting digestion and urinary tract health, and discouraging hairballs.
Pros
- High protein and moisture content
- The texture of the meat is soft enough for cats with sensitive or missing teeth
- Senior cats seem to really like the taste
- Affordable
Cons
- Wet food only comes in pates and flaked meat
- High carbohydrate content
- Low calorie, so it’s not appropriate for cats who need to gain weight
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
3. Blue Buffalo Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipes
A hearty dose of red meat forms the basis of all of Blue Buffalo’s Rocky Mountain Recipe canned adult cat food. The newest in the Wilderness collection, the Rocky Mountain Recipe contains novel proteins such as bison, venison, lamb, making this a viable choice for cats who have food sensitivities or allergies to many of the standard meats used in the cat food industry.
Blue Buffalo’s Rocky Mountain Recipe is ideal for supporting muscle function, nerve health, eyesight, GI tract, heart health, and general quality of life. There’s also just one veggie in this recipe: potatoes, so cat parents concerned about feeding their cats excessive plant proteins (or carbs) can cross that off their list.
Pros
- High protein and highly digestible
- No meat by-products, gluten, grains, soy, or corn
- Potatoes are the only vegetable
- There are flavors without any chicken
- May be good for cats with protein sensitivities and allergies
Cons
- Premium price
- Some flavors contain carrageenan
- Fish oil is in many of the recipes so it’s not appropriate for cats with fish allergies or sensitivities
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
4. Blue Buffalo Wilderness
Inspired by Lynx and other wild cat diets, Blue Buffalo Wilderness wet cat food is chock full of high-quality meats. This high-protein, grain-free wet food for adult cats contains whole salmon, chicken, and duck, with vitamin and omega-3 packed flax seeds and potatoes.
Fortified with essential vitamins, minerals, and amino acids, Blue Buffalo Wilderness helps cats maintain a healthy metabolism, vision, skin, and regular nerve function. The ingredients also contribute to heart health, brain health, and muscle formation.
Pros
- No meat by-products, gluten, corn, soy, or grains
- Limited vegetable ingredients
- Contains high levels of taurine
- Moderate carb and fat content
Cons
- Can be pricey
- For adult and mature cats only
- Some flavors contain carrageenan
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
Blue Buffalo ‘Healthy Gourmet’ varieties
Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Natural canned cat food comes in four varieties. Adult cats can enjoy pates, meaty morsels, and flaked wet cat food. In this line, there are also cans of pate wet cat food for kittens.
5. Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Flaked Wet Cat Food
A light gravy accompanies flaked tuna, shrimp, or chicken in Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet’s flaked wet cat food line. Like the other Blue Buffalo foods crafted for adult indoor cat’s optimal health and wellness, the flaked wet cat foods are full of high-quality meats, plant proteins, vitamins, minerals, and other essential nutrients. This line is especially good for supporting bone health, vision, lean muscle, and the immune system. Fiber from flax seeds and antioxidants from cranberries also help maintain urinary tract function and aid digestion and G.I. tract health.
Pros
- No meat by-products, corn, wheat, soy, or artificial flavors
- Cats who don’t like pate may like the meatier texture
- High protein, high moisture, and highly digestible
- Affordable
Cons
- Not appropriate for cats with fish allergies or sensitivities
- Some flavors contain carrageenan
- Vegetable and grain-heavy
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
6. Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Pate Wet Cat Food
The pates in the Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet wet cat food line are formulated for indoor adult cats with ingredients to meet their specific needs. These smooth pates with chunks of meat are especially palatable for finicky cats who are fussy about food texture. Based on real high-quality meats and animal proteins and fortified with antioxidants, these pates are especially effective at boosting your kitty’s immune system. They help them maintain a healthy weight and lean muscle and support heart health.
Pros
- No meat by-products, corn, wheat, soy, or artificial flavors
- Chicken and tuna are the top ingredients
- High protein, high moisture, and highly digestible
- Affordable
Cons
- Vegetable and grain-heavy
- Some cats may not like the texture of the pates
- There are only a few flavors
- Some flavors contain carrageenan
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
7. Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Meaty Morsels Wet Cat Food
What sets the meaty morsels apart from the other wet cat foods in the Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet line is how chewy, chunky, and textured the meat is. Unlike smooth pates or flaked varieties, the meaty morsels are, well, morsels! With ingredients like iron-rich chicken liver and urinary tract health-supporting cranberries, Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet meaty morsels promote overall health and wellness for your kitty.
Pros
- No meat by-products, corn, wheat, soy, or artificial flavors
- Chicken and tuna are the top ingredients
- High protein, high moisture, and highly digestible
- Affordable
Cons
- Vegetable and grain-heavy
- Only comes in a few flavors
- Some flavors contain carrageenan
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
Blue Buffalo kitten food
8. Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Kitten Pate Wet Cat Food
Real deboned chicken is the first ingredient in Blue Buffalo’s Healthy Gourmet Natural kitten food. This wet pate food is expertly crafted by animal nutritionists and veterinarians to meet all the major nutritional needs of young kitties.
Fortified with taurine, biotin, and folic acid, among other essential fatty acids, vitamins, and minerals, Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Natural kitten food is a fully nutritionally balanced choice for all mealtimes. Ingredients like fish oil, sweet potatoes, and chicken liver help build and improve immune system health, lean muscle development, kidney health, brain function, and general growth.
Pros
- High protein and fortified with extra essential nutrients
- Highly digestible and high moisture
- No meat by-products, corn, wheat, or soy
- Tends to make kittens hair extra soft and shiny
- Affordable
Cons
- Only comes in one flavor
- Contains carrageenan
- Fish oil is an ingredient, so kittens with fish allergies may not be able to eat this
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
9. Baby Blue Healthy Growth Formula Kitten Wet Cat Food
An alternative to Blue Buffalo’s Healthy Gourmet line of kitten food is their Baby Blue Healthy Growth Formula. Like the last line of kitten food, Baby Blue Healthy Growth Formula is packed with vitamins, minerals, essential fatty acids, taurine, and DHA to provide optimal kittens nutrition. The meat-first recipes contain fewer vegetable ingredients than many of Blue’s adult cat food lines. The ones they do include, like potatoes, are an excellent source of potassium, vitamin B, iron, and magnesium. There are even two grain-free varieties.
Pros
- High protein and moisture
- Fortified with extra essential nutrients like DHA and ARA
- No meat by-products, corn, wheat, or soy
- Grain free options
- Affordable
Cons
- Only comes in three flavors
- Contain fish so it’s not appropriate for kittens with fish allergies or sensitivities
- Some flavors contain carrageenan
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
What are cat parents saying about Blue Buffalo foods?
Blue Buffalo is one of the most widely reviewed cat foods on pet food retailer websites. With that in mind, we’ve assembled together some of the top positive and negative reviews of Blue Buffalo’s wet cat food.
Positive Blue Buffalo reviews
“My older kitty with missing teeth loves this food and seems to have an easier time eating it than some of the other foods we’ve tried. He cleans his bowl and doesn’t just lick the gravy off and leave the bits.” GrumpemsMcMeow on Chewy.com (Blue Buffalo Wilderness Wild Delights Chicken & Turkey in Tasty Gravy)
“This wet food is perfect for kittens and young cats. It was easy on my 2-month-old kitten’s stomach and even though she was underweight and malnourished when I got her, she had zero issues eating this.” Luna9689 on Petco.com (Blue Buffalo Blue Healthy Gourmet Chicken Entree Kitten Food)
“So glad to find high-quality food that our adopted cat will eat. He is thin & tiny and was clearly used to low price, low-quality brands. It’s been tough to get him to upgrade to a healthier diet, but he LOVES this food and we feel so much better that he’s eating good quality.” Jackie Woo Woo on Petco.com (Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Pate Ocean Fish & Tuna)
Negative Blue Buffalo reviews
“I decided to change my cat’s mainly poultry-based wet food diet up with some red meat. (Really, who doesn’t get bored of chicken?) Big mistake. The picky eater will eat a few bites and then leave the rest while meowing at my feet for food. I’m out over $20, and stuck with a case of cans he won’t eat.” MurphyCatsHuman on Chewy.com (Blue Buffalo Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipe Flaked Red Meat Feast Adult Grain-Free Canned Cat Food)
“After reading several reviews about how this was one of the best cat foods for indoor cats, we had really high hopes that our picky felines would like this wet food. One of our cats eats it less than half the time, the other one just tries to bury it. The only pet that likes it is the dog 🙁 Time to donate yet another batch of food to the shelter.” Nikki on Chewy.com (Blue Buffalo Freedom Indoor Adult Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Canned Cat Food)
“I thought my cat would like something new. No such luck. He did not seem to like the large chunks of food and sniffed and walked away. It was expensive so I was a bit disappointed. I will probably donate it to the local cat shelter.” Corgimom on Chewy.com (Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Flaked Chicken Entree in Gravy Canned Cat Food)
The takeaway
The biggest concern among cat parents when it comes to buying Blue Buffalo wet cat food is that many recipes contain a fair amount of vegetable ingredients. And carrageenan, a controversial plant-based thickening agent linked to inflammation, appears in several of Blue Buffalo’s wet cat food lines.
Beyond that, Blue Buffalo is a reliable, nutritionally balanced, and budget-friendly brand. It offers some of the largest varieties of flavors, textures, and nutritional profiles of wet cat food and has hundreds of rave reviews online that are a testament to just how many finicky felines Blue Buffalo has won over.
All of Blue Buffalo’s wet cat foods start with highly digestible meats and feature vitamin and antioxidant plant-based ingredients, without any artificial flavors, meat by-products, wheat, corn, soy. And there are options for cats of all ages, life stages, and dietary needs. Blue Buffalo is receptive to customer demands and individual cats’ needs.
We encourage cat parents to closely read all nutritional labels when choosing any cat food– wet or dry. When in doubt, reach out to your vet for more in-depth answers to your feline nutrition questions and concerns.
- 25 Easy Litter Box Hacks For a Fresh Smelling Home - February 3, 2022
- 15 Best High Fiber Cat Foods For Your Constipated Cat - December 19, 2021
- How Much Crude Protein Should Be in Cat Food? - December 19, 2021